Some Reflections on Christmas

I’ve decided it’s because we are aware, at the deepest level of our hearts and souls, that all we do and spend and suffer—and surely know we will do again—in the name of this guy Santa Claus is done in order to make someone else happy.

Wowzer! I turned around twice and it’s already seven days after Christmas. Our earth has bid that happy occasion adieu without a second thought and already made seven journeys around the sun on its way to Christmas, 2024. It’s always a bit of a shock that after all of the preparation and anticipation, Christmas day comes and goes in the blink of an eye.
And here we are, already a full week later. A mere three hundred and fifty-eight revolutions from now, we will arrive once more, together, on the one day above all others that families seem to remember they are family. And an annoying collection of humans that includes myself are already saying, “Well, only three hundred and fifty-eight days until Christmas!” Forgive us. We can’t help it. We really do love Christmas that much.
Can it really, already be only seven days after we have survived the pressures, the frenetic, often frantic preparations, that accompany this happiest, warmest, most magical but also most demanding of holidays; a week that flew by so speedily we know it will be no time at all before we find ourselves, parents, spouses, siblings, grandparents, in-laws, each and every one of us, scurrying about again, decorating, shopping, balancing shrinking checking accounts and growing credit card balances, and fretting over whether this thing or that one is right for Uncle Lewis, Aunt Franny, Grandma and Grandpa, and where in the world they are going to find that electric train or video game or doll house that had somehow been forgotten ,and was now seemingly non-existent no matter how many stores they visited. And the cooking, oh my God the cooking, and cleaning up after the cooking, and making those oh so sincere vows to diet for a month afterward.
In no time at all, children will start to flex their fingers, in practice for ripping the bows and wrappings all the faster off of their rewards for being mostly, or at least somewhat, good enough—because they did after all try—to deserve the joyous things that will sit mocking them beneath the tree for days or even weeks inside their shiny wrappings glittering once again under the colored lights, tantalizing blinking and winking.
And in spite of it all, the hustle, the bustle, the stresses of wanting to make the day as perfect as possible or perhaps, just maybe, because of it all, Christmas remains the happiest day of the year for the vast majority of us who celebrate it. Oh, we will sweat and grouch, overspend, again, shop with increasingly frantic, breathless, anxiety-ridden angst as the day grows closer. We’ll scratch our head, grind our teeth, pray that this time we get it all right, and vow that after this one we will never succumb to the ‘demands’ of the season so deeply or readily. Who are we kidding? Every single time we vow it, knowing all the time that yes, or course we will.
I’ve decided it’s because we are aware, at the deepest level of our hearts and souls, that all we do and spend and suffer—and surely know we will do again—in the name of this guy Santa Claus, this famous, white-bearded, elusive old fat guy in his red suit and bottomless sleigh propelled at faster than light speeds throughout the world in a single night by magical reindeer, is done in order to make someone else happy. There is a special joy, a deep satisfaction, accompanying the smiles and appreciation of adults simply because they have been given something that didn’t really have to be given; it comes to us three-fold, nay, ten-fold, in the exclamations, laughter, and unbounded delight of children that we can only wish would be theirs all year-round. How, those of us driven by merciless and heartless logic always ask, did we get here?
The legend of Santa Claus can be traced back hundreds of years to a monk named St. Nicholas. It is believed that Nicholas was born sometime around A.D. 280 in Patara, near Myra in modern-day Turkey. Much admired for his piety and kindness, St. Nicholas became the subject of many legends. It is said that he gave away all of his inherited wealth and traveled the countryside helping the poor and sick. One of the best-known St. Nicholas stories is the time he saved three poor sisters from being sold into slavery or prostitution by their father by providing them with a dowry so that they could be married.
Good old St. Nicholas has of course been commercialized in modern times more than anything except professional football. And yet the forever jolly old guy has never, that we know of, thrown, caught, kicked or hit a ball of any kind. He merely and happily delivers them. However, even as we may grouse about the commercializing of a ritual that, in its earliest days consisted, for most people, of exchanging gifts that were handmade at home, and bemoan the attaching of dollar signs to gifting which might often feel ‘required,’ we have deep within us an awareness that at the foundation it all is the desire to give of ourselves to others; we derive an indefinable and quietly overwhelming satisfaction from the warmth and fellowship, that passes between us and them. And there is this which I have learned; there is no happiness greater, no joy that fills the heart more, than contributing to the happiness of children.
Oh, I know some say they only go through all of the hassle of Christmas because they have to; it is expected of them. But even if that is somewhat of a factor for many, look me in the eye if you can, and tell me those same people don’t feel rewarded and perhaps a tiny bit larger at the happy gratefulness of those who receive a gift, and in return give one. Perhaps in some grander scheme, we need that little push to give something of ourselves. And I submit that is the rare individual who doesn’t feel better for having done it.
As the core of this Christmas tradition of ours is found in the caring and generosity of a spiritual individual, there is no denying that Christmas is also founded in the best aspects of religion, yet I have come to feel that there is perhaps a greater spirituality in the personage of St. Nick, Santa Claus, than any God of whom or which I am aware. To the best of my knowledge and research, no one has ever killed in the name of Santa, or pushed away a needy stranger, waged war, or committed genocide. Good old St. Nicholas has apparently never cared about gender or sexuality, politics or the accumulation of power. Santa cares for all the little children, not just the ones with an acceptable skin color or head covering. So I hope that no religion, including Christianity, which claims the holiday as its own, ever succeeds in dismissing Santa Claus as simply a representative of commerce. The old fellow is no less than the messenger who reminds us always of the traits that make us the best version of ourselves.
And so I say to you three hundred and fifty-eight days early, from the depths of my own heart and the fullness of my soul which still glows a bit from the most recent version, Merry Christmas to all, this year, next year, and through all the years that follow, and may we all, always, know our very best selves and the pure joy of giving and fellowship on each and every Christmas day.

BW

Yes, GONE WITH THE WIND Should be Shelved

I think GWTW is perhaps the greatest example of cinematic art in American film. Scripting, costuming, cinematography, scoring, grandness, emotional impact. I do not think you’ll find a purely American film that is better in the eighty-on years since its release. I understand the sad irony of having Hattie McDaniel’s wonderful performance shaded by any restricting of this movie. But I will add these bits of information about her award.

Loew’s Grand Theater on Peachtree Street in Atlanta, Georgia was selected by the studio as the site for the Friday, December 15, 1939 premiere of Gone with the Wind. Studio head David O. Selznick asked that McDaniel be permitted to attend, but MGM advised him not to, because of Georgia’s segregation laws. Clark Gable threatened to boycott the Atlanta premiere unless McDaniel were allowed to attend, but McDaniel convinced him to attend anyway.

McDaniel received a plaque-style Oscar, approximately 5.5 inches (14 cm) by 6 inches (15 cm), the type awarded to all Best Supporting Actors and Actresses at that time.[33] She and her escort were required to sit at a segregated table for two at the far wall of the room; her white agent, William Meiklejohn, sat at the same table. The hotel had a strict no-blacks policy, but allowed McDaniel in as a favor.[34][35] The discrimination continued after the award ceremony as well as her white costars went to a “no-blacks” club, where McDaniel was also denied entry.

I believe that in terms of racist impact, GWTW is—and always has been—more dangerous than D.W. Griffith’s “Birth of a Nation.” Griffith’s film so powerfully exhibits the hatred, destruction, and vileness of racism that it delivers to any intelligent audience the exact reverse of the message Griffith intended. GWTW, however, does just the opposite. It paints this romanticized picture of a lovely south and a mostly benign image of slavery that makes it easy for people to accept the “Slavery wasn’t all bad, slaves were happy and well cared for…” illusion. Though it vividly depicts the destruction of slavery and the old south, it does so with a nostalgic sadness. It does little, if anything at all, to address the reality of slavery, or the Jim Crow era that followed. I don’t think the film is going to disappear, in the same way as Disney’s “Song of the South” rightfully did. I believe it may have a prologue and perhaps even an epilogue attached and still be available for purchase. It will undoubtedly be seen on University campuses and in film schools. But the sad reality is that as individuals, and societies, grow and mature, some things that were beloved along the way must be examined under a bright light recognized as the negative reality they hid, instead of the romanticized fantasies they presented.

While we celebrate Labor Day. . .

While we celebrate Labor Day. . .

One of the great incongruities, and condemnations, of Christianity is that black Americans and white Americans both prayed to the same God, from the Civil War, through the Jim Crow era, which has ‘ended’ only in our imaginations right up to present day America, where that conundrum continues.
And while black Americans prayed and strove—almost always peacefully—right up to today, for the simple freedom of equality, white Americans have responded, and respond today, with guns and fires and explosives and other forms of violence. This has always been supported by the conservative church through means ranging from cowardly silence to active participation.
So much for the image of a ‘just’ God, and Godly “Christians.”
Wonder no more about why modern Americans increasingly turn away from this religion awash in its own hatred, bigotry and hypocrisy.
Here ends the sermon.

Labor Day And The Elaine Massacre Of 1919

The Awful Truth Behind Franklin’s Warning

I finally figured out what Ben Franklin tried to tell us, and it’s more scary now than at any time I can remember. At the close of the Constitutional Convention of 1787,  Franklin was queried as he left Independence Hall on the final day of deliberation. In the notes of Dr. James McHenry, one of Maryland’s delegates to the Convention,  a lady asked Franklin, “Well Doctor what have we got, a republic or a monarchy.”  Franklin replied, “A republic . . . if you can keep it.” I have used that quote numerous times, during the 2016 election and since. But the full import, the dispiriting and frightening truth behind Franklin’s words, didn’t become fully clear to me until today.

 I was napping on the sofa, and struggled to consciousness through the hard to escape fog of a particularly realistic dream. You know, one of those that doesn’t want to let you go. It was a dream about a house of illusions, in which my companion and I pursued an illusory character through a series of rooms, each room a scene that presented a peril or a dilemma before the laughing villainous again revealed herself, taunting us and leading us on to the next scenario.

None of the scenes in that house of illusions was especially horrific. But when we exited through the final door, without ever catching up with our prey, we weren’t sure it was really over. For several moments, we looked around warily for another door, waiting for the minions of this particular scene to descend upon us. Such was the totality of the effect. At the end, you see, we weren’t sure the adventure was over, so firmly convinced we were that nothing was as it seemed.

My subconscious mind must have been quietly connecting synapses while I poured a cup of coffee. By the time I sat down at the computer, thinking to do some writing, the reality of Dr. Franklin’s statement overcame me. When we think of that comment we usually and appropriately connect it to the Constitution itself. But the subtle dangers inherent in our Constitution go all the way back to a phrase in the Declaration of Independence, the fundamental, foundational document at the root of America’s existence. Franklin said, on that final day of deliberations, “We have given you a republic, if you can keep it.” The second paragraph of the Declaration begins with “ We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal…”

That statement is at the core of the Constitution. It means everybody, both good and bad, honorable and dishonorable, loving and bigoted, truthful and non-truthful. It grants equal voice and rights to those who embrace the Constitution, and the Republic, and the freedoms they represent for all Americans, as well as those who would manipulate the former and disassemble the latter for their own purposes.

Ben Franklin’s warning had nothing to do with threats to America from without. It warned us about the Republic’s vulnerability to attacks from within. He was telling us that our Constitution didn’t include the word ‘forever.’  It still doesn’t. Its existence is always vulnerable, subject to attack, due to its most fundamental principal. All men are created equal. The freedom promised to everyone by one of the most forward thinking documents of governance in the history of the world, is in constant peril, because in order to guarantee the freedom of all, it could not exclude any, including those who would commandeer that freedom for themselves and their followers.

The Bill of Rights reaffirmed that guarantee of freedom for all, free speech for all, the right to assemble and be heard and run for office and seek to control the government, for all. Bigots, have your go. White (or any other color) nationalists, take your shot. Religious extremists of any ilk, go for the gold ring. Control of this country is yours for the taking, if you can manage it.

“We gave you a republic, if you can keep it.” The subtle hidden message within that statement warns us that the scoundrels and thieves, tyrants and haters of others, religious extremists and greed mongers also have the right to take it away from us.  Franklin warned us that they will, on the day that the rest of us, those of us who truly believe  all men, and women, are created equal, give up; the day that those of us who believe ‘love your neighbor’ means everyone, not just the ones who are the same color as me, or have the same sexuality as me, or the same religion as me, are no longer the majority; the day those of us who believe that America is a nation of people, not corporations, lose the will to stand against those who would usurp our Constitution for their own personal agendas. Because the evil among us is always looking and hoping for the opportunity.

“We gave you a republic, if you can keep it.” Benjamin Franklin was warning us that in order to guarantee the rights of all, our forefathers had to take a terrible risk that the very freedoms they guaranteed to everyone might someday be relinquished, to those who were loud enough, and determined enough, and ruthless enough. He was warning us that our Republic would serve and stand for everyone only as long as we remained determined  it would do so.  The enemy is not out there, it is within us. And today it is stronger and more determined than I have seen within my lifetime, to take our country for all the people, away from everyone in favor of their chosen few.

May 14, 2017, 6:45pm. Just as nothing was as it seemed in my little dream, I’ve come to realize there was much more than there seemed to be in Ben Franklin’s statement. The Constitution we so treasure and the world admires, in guaranteeing the rights of all, also guarantees the right of those who would destroy it, to do so. We have to ask ourselves, are we strong enough, determined enough, to keep our Republic for all the people? ###

NO, It’s Not Okay

*Miy response to all of those well-meaning (and not so well-meaning) people telling me not to ‘overreact.’  Just relax, ‘they’ say, and it will be okay.  No. It won’t. Not without a fight.

Benjamin Franklin was asked, “Well Doctor, what have we got, a Republic or a Monarchy?” To which he replied, “A Republic, if you can keep it.” In that reply is a warning, that we must be ever vigilant and prepared to fight to keep the Republic our Founding Fathers crafted.

Don’t tell me to relax. Don’t tell me I’m overreacting. Don’t tell me it will be okay.

No reason for alarm? The nature of Donald Trump has been exhibited consistently throughout his career, displayed by his own words and actions. The word sociopath has been applied to him not just by myself, but by observers including psychologists, based on his behavior and what comes out of his mouth.

No reason for alarm? He wonders why we do not use nuclear weapons. He does not believe in global warming, the perils of our streams and rivers and animal life, the dangers to the environment, and selected as a running mate a man who is a creationist and believes homosexuality can be ‘cured,’ a man who actually believes in forcing ‘therapy’ upon the LGBT community.

No reason for alarm? Donald nurtured and received the support of the kkk, white supremacists, a criminal foreign national with his own agenda, Julian Assange, who helped Trump’s campaign with very selective, stolen and doctored private emails.

No reason for alarm? Donald Trump asked for and benefited from the assistance of one foreign nation, Russia, whose leader he admires, and is celebrated by one of the most repressive regimes on earth, North Korea. He is celebrated by Syria’s regime and by ISIS.

No reason for alarm? Trump has the support of a vindictive religious extremism and reaches out to it.

No reason for alarm? Germany was also a democracy before the citizenry invited Adolf Hitler to take over. The German government had checks and balances, though they weren’t as strong as those in the United States. The German people relinquished their checks and balances little by little, until Hitler had enough power to cancel the rest of them.

No reason for alarm? Religious extremism and white supremacy now control our Presidency, as of January, 2017.

No reason for alarm? That same religious extremism and white supremacy also controls both houses of our Congress, and has cowed the moderates within the once Republican party. There is no effective voice of reason existing within their party.

No reason for alarm? This religiously extreme white nationalist supremacy group now has it within their reach to also control the Supreme Court.

No reason for alarm?
Checks and balances. The Executive, strike one.
Checks and balances. The Legislative. Strike two.
Checks and balances, The Supreme Court. Strike three and out.

No reason for alarm? If you are really trying to tell those of us who study history, those of us who know that this Republic exists for everyone or it exists for no one, to sit back and relax and it will be all right, you are either one of the people behind the curtain, or delusional, or simply in a state of extreme hope because you are afraid to face the possibility of the Republic collapsing within itself.

No reason for alarm?
“Well Doctor, what have we got, a Republic or a Monarchy?”
“A Republic, if you can keep it.”
In that reply is a warning, that we must be ever vigilant and prepared to fight to keep the Republic our Founding Fathers crafted. I choose to believe there is every reason for alarm. I choose to keep that Republic. I choose to fight.

No reason for alarm? You might want consider choosing to wake up.